⏱️ Estimated reading time: 21 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
Work through five decisions in order. Pick the comfort rating for the coldest night you expect, with a few degrees of margin. Match the season. Choose down or synthetic fill for your conditions. Check the shape and length against how you sleep and how tall you are. Then weigh up weight, pack size and zips for how you travel.
For most UK campsites from late spring to early autumn, a bag with a comfort rating of around 0 °C covers the nights you are likely to meet, provided you sleep on a decent mat. Upland pitches, early spring, late autumn and winter need a lower comfort figure. Plan around real night-time lows, not daytime temperatures.
They are three figures from the same lab method. Comfort is the lowest temperature at which a typical cold sleeper rests relaxed. Limit is where a typical warm sleeper gets through the night curled up. Extreme is a survival figure that marks where the insulation runs out. Buy by comfort and never plan a night around extreme.
Synthetic fill keeps more of its loft when it gets damp and dries faster, which suits damp campsites, festivals and campervans. Down gives the most warmth for its weight and packs smaller, which suits cold, drier nights and longer walks. If you choose down, keep it dry, air it every morning and store it loosely.
A mummy cut is tapered, so there is less air to heat, and it is warmer for its weight, but it leaves less room to move. A rectangular cut gives more space for side sleepers and restless sleepers and often opens flat, but it is cooler and bulkier. Choose by the coldest night and by how you like to lie.
No. A sleeping bag is insulation, not a shelter. Some outer fabrics resist wind or shrug off a little condensation, but none replaces a tent, a bivvy bag or a dry pitch. Keep the bag off wet ground, ventilate the tent to reduce condensation and air the bag in the morning.
Yes. The insulation underneath you is squashed flat by your body weight, so without a mat the ground draws heat straight out of you. Temperature ratings assume a mat. Mats are compared by R-value: higher numbers insulate more, and cold or frozen ground and hard floors need a higher figure.
How to choose a sleeping bag in short: start with the comfort rating for the coldest night you expect, leave a margin of a few degrees, and then narrow it down by season, fill, shape and size, and finally weight, pack size and zips. A good mat and dry layers matter as much as the bag. An extreme figure is a survival limit, never a sleeping target.
Most people choose a sleeping bag by price, colour or the lowest number on the label, and then spend a cold night finding out what that number meant. This guide does it the other way round. It starts from the nights you will actually sleep through, whether that is a July festival, a damp May weekend in the Lakes, a campervan in October or a frosty hut night, and works back to the bag that suits them.
You will find a five-step decision flow, a section on which bag fits which kind of night, a short box on what an extreme figure does not mean, and a look at the rest of your sleep system. Each section links to a deeper guide, starting with our explainer on sleeping bag temperature ratings, because that is the decision people most often get wrong. We also show how our own two models compare, spec by spec, so you can judge them the same way you would judge any bag.
The five-step decision flow
Every choice below narrows the field. Do them in this order, because the first two decide how much insulation you need, and the last three decide how that insulation is packaged.
- Rating: find the comfort temperature for the coldest night you expect, plus a margin.
- Season: check that the season label on the shelf matches that number.
- Fill: choose down or synthetic for the conditions you camp in.
- Shape and size: match the cut to how you sleep and the length to your height.
- Weight, pack size and zips: make sure it suits how you travel and how you like to ventilate.
Step 1: Choose the temperature rating
Bags sold with a standardised rating carry up to three temperatures. They come from one lab test in which a heated mannequin lies in the bag on a mat in a cold chamber, and a model turns the measured insulation into three figures.
- Comfort: the lowest temperature at which a typical cold sleeper rests relaxed and warm. This is the figure that answers “will I be warm?”
- Limit: the lowest temperature at which a typical warm sleeper gets through the night curled up. Acceptable, not cosy.
- Extreme: a survival figure. The cold is a real danger at this point, and the figure only marks where the insulation runs out.
The European method used to be EN 13537. It has been replaced by the international standard ISO 23537-1, and the current edition has been valid since 18 March 2022, according to the Estonian standards body’s catalogue entry for ISO 23537-1:2022. The standard covers bags designed for limit temperatures of −20 °C and higher. A figure tested to it lets you compare two bags fairly. A figure without a name may come from a maker’s own method, so always check which of the three numbers a label is quoting.
Then pick your number. Our rule of thumb: decide honestly whether you sleep cold or warm, find the coldest night you realistically expect, and choose a comfort rating a few degrees below it, around 5 °C if you feel the cold. The margin covers what a lab cannot: a damp evening, wind through the door, a night when you are worn out after a long day.
For the coldest night, use night-time lows rather than daytime temperatures. The Met Office publishes long-term climate averages for UK locations, including average minimum temperatures for each month over 1991 to 2020. Averages hide the coldest nights of a month, and a valley floor or high camp can sit well below the nearest station. Our month-by-month guide to what temperature bag you need for UK camping turns those figures into suggested comfort ratings.
What an extreme figure is not
- It is not a comfort rating. You cannot work out a comfort or limit figure from it, so never guess one.
- It is not a sleeping target. Plan your nights well above it and judge warmth by a comfort figure.
- It is not a promise that you will be fine. It describes a night in which the cold is a serious danger.
- It is not proof of a standard test. Check whether a figure was measured to the standard or set by the maker.
Our Explorer Warm PRO Down, for example, publishes only an extreme rating of −25 °C. No comfort or limit figure is published for it, and we will not invent one.
Step 2: Match the season
Shops sort bags into 1 to 5 seasons. The labels are handy shorthand, but they are not a standard, and two brands can mean different temperatures by the same label. As a rough guide:
- 1 season: warm summer nights, roughly +10 °C and above. Festivals, hostels, indoor use.
- 2 season: late spring to early autumn, roughly +5 °C and above. Lowland campsites in mild weather.
- 3 season: spring to autumn, comfort around 0 °C to −5 °C. Most UK camping outside winter.
- 4 season: all year, including frosty nights, usually −5 °C or colder.
- 5 season: expedition use, well below −10 °C.
Always read the temperature behind the label. A “3-season” bag with a comfort rating of +5 °C is a very different bag from one rated to a comfort of −5 °C. Our guide to what 3-season and 4-season mean lines up the labels with real months and trips.
Step 3: Choose the fill
Insulation comes in two families, and each wins in different conditions.
- Down gives the most warmth for its weight and compresses very small. It loses loft when it gets wet and dries slowly, and it needs a down detergent and careful drying. It rewards people who walk far and keep their kit dry.
- Synthetic fill is heavier and bulkier for the same warmth, but it keeps more of its loft when damp, dries faster and is easy to wash. It suits damp British campsites, festivals, campervans and anyone who camps from the car.
In the UK, damp matters as much as cold. Condensation inside a tent on a still night can soak the outside of a bag by morning. If you choose down, ventilate the tent, keep the bag off wet groundsheets and air it whenever you can. Our full comparison of down vs synthetic goes through warmth, packing, care and lifespan.
Step 4: Get the shape and size right
Shape is a trade between warmth and room. A tapered mummy cut has less empty air to heat, so it is warmer for its weight, but it holds your shoulders, hips and feet close. A rectangular or semi-rectangular cut gives side sleepers and restless sleepers space to turn and often unzips into a quilt, at the cost of some warmth and bulk. Our guide to mummy vs rectangular compares the main cuts.
Length matters just as much. Too short and your feet compress the insulation at the end, which leaves a cold spot. Far too long and you have a pocket of cold air to warm up. A common rule of thumb is a bag around 15 to 25 cm longer than your height, more if you like to pull the hood right over your head or keep a water bottle and tomorrow’s clothes inside. Width at the shoulders decides whether you can lie on your side with your knees bent. Our guide on what size sleeping bag you need has a height-by-length table.
Step 5: Weigh up weight, pack size and zips
If the car is parked next to the tent, weight and pack size barely matter. If you carry everything on your back, they matter a lot. Check the weight of the bag itself, the packed size in its compression sack and whether it fits the bottom of your rucksack with room for a mat and stove. Our guide to a sleeping bag for backpacking goes into the balance between warmth and grams.
Zips are the most underrated feature. A full-length zip lets you vent on a warm night, and a zip that also opens the foot end lets you cool your feet without letting cold air in at the shoulders. Bags that open flat double as a quilt for a campervan or a guest bed. If you hope to join two bags into one, the zips have to match in type and length and sit on opposite sides; our guide to zipping two sleeping bags together explains what to check. And whatever you buy, learn how to pack a sleeping bag so it fits your rucksack and lofts again at night.
Arctic Shield 250 vs Explorer Warm PRO Down: the specs side by side
Here are our own two models, run through the same checklist. The table uses only the published specifications. Where a figure is not published, we say so rather than fill the gap.
| Specification | Arctic Shield 250 | Explorer Warm PRO Down |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature rating | Comfort to 0 °C | Extreme −25 °C, no comfort figure published |
| Filling | 100 % polyester | 50 % duck down |
| Outer and inner fabric | Polyester / polyester | 400T polyester / 400T polyester; outer wind-resistant, inner soft on the skin |
| Size | 210 × 65 cm | 230 × 80 × 50 cm, room for tall people and side sleepers |
| Packed | Approx. 35 × Ø 40 cm | Compresses small enough for a trekking rucksack |
| Weight | 1.2 kg | 1.5 kg |
| Zips | Zips on both sides: open the foot end to air it, or open it fully into a blanket | No zip details published |
| Hood | Drawstring hood | Drawstring hood |
| In the box | Bag and compression sack | Bag and compression sack |
| Colour | Grey | Green |
| Care | 30 °C gentle cycle, no fabric softener | 30 °C with down detergent, tumble dry low with two tennis balls |
| Typical nights | Spring to autumn: tent, festival, campervan, guest bed | Frosty nights: tent, van, mountain hut |
For the nights most people actually camp, from April to October, the Arctic Shield 250, comfort to 0 °C, is the straightforward choice. Its comfort figure is the number to plan around, its synthetic filling copes with damp campsites and is easy to wash, and the zips on both sides make it unusually flexible: crack the foot end open on a warm festival night or open it right out as a blanket in the campervan.
For frosty nights there is the Explorer Warm PRO Down (50 % duck down, extreme rating −25 °C). Read that figure as an extreme rating, a survival limit and nothing more: no comfort or limit figure is published for it. What it does offer is a 50 % duck down filling, a wind-resistant 400T outer and a long, wide 230 × 80 × 50 cm cut that leaves room for winter layers and for lying on your side. The frosty-night section below explains what else a cold night asks of you.
Which bag for which night
Instead of a ranking of the “best” bags, here is what each common kind of night asks of a sleeping bag. Find yours and work from there.
Summer festival
Festival nights swing from loud and warm at midnight to surprisingly cold at 3 am and hot again once the sun hits the tent. You want a bag you can vent: a comfort rating around 0 °C to +5 °C, synthetic fill that copes with a damp field, and zips that open the foot end or the whole bag. A mat matters even in July. Our guide to sleeping well at a festival covers pitching, noise and dawn light.
UK 3-season tent
A weekend in the Lakes, the Peak District or Eryri between spring and autumn is the classic British trip. Nights near 0 °C are common on higher pitches even in late spring, and dew or condensation is almost guaranteed. A comfort rating of around 0 °C, a mat suited to cool ground and a ventilated tent cover most of these nights. Our guide on how to sleep in a tent covers the rest, from pitching on flat ground to keeping condensation down. Planning to go further from the road? Read our guides to wild camping in the UK and sleeping in a bivvy bag.
Campervan
In a van, weight and pack size hardly matter, but space and damp do. A bag that opens fully into a blanket can be a quilt on warm nights and a closed bag on cold ones, and synthetic fill shrugs off the condensation that builds up overnight. Our guide on choosing a sleeping bag or duvet in a campervan weighs up both options. For a night in an ordinary car, read our guide to sleeping in a car, including the safety points. Never run the engine, a stove or an unvented heater for warmth in a closed space.
Hut, hostel or bothy
Indoors, you are out of the wind, but floors are hard and cold and mountain huts and bothies are often unheated. Some staffed huts and hostels provide bedding and ask you to bring a liner instead, so check before you go; our hut-to-hut packing list and our guide on whether you need a sleeping bag in a hostel explain what to take. An unstaffed bothy is different. The Mountain Bothies Association advises assuming there will be no facilities and no beds, and on a busy night the only space may be a stone floor, so bring your own bag and a mat. Our guide to sleeping in a bothy covers what to bring.
Frosty or winter night
Below freezing, every part of the system has to work: a bag with a low comfort figure or generous insulation, a well-insulated mat, dry layers, a hat and a sheltered pitch. Mountaineering Scotland’s winter camping advice makes a simple point worth remembering: once the tent is up, it is far easier to stay warm than to get chilled and then warm up again, so on a very cold evening get into your sleeping bag early. Our guide to choosing a winter sleeping bag explains how to judge warmth when a label gives only an extreme figure.
Your sleep system: mat, liner, earplugs and mask
A sleeping bag is one part of a good night outdoors. The other parts are cheap to get right and easy to forget.
- Mat: the bag’s insulation is crushed underneath you, so the mat does the work there. Mats are compared by R-value under the ASTM F3340 test method; our guide on what R-value mat you need explains the bands.
- Liner: a liner keeps the bag clean, adds a little warmth and is often all you need in a staffed hut. Read more on sleeping bag liners.
- Layers: dry base layers, socks and a hat add warmth; damp clothes from the day take it away. Our guide on what to wear in a sleeping bag covers the layers in detail, and our guide on how to stay warm in a sleeping bag covers the safe ways to add warmth.
- Quiet: campsites are rarely silent: zips, generators, late arrivals, wind on the flysheet. Reusable sleep earplugs such as Life+ (SNR 24 dB, hypoallergenic silicone, a low profile for side sleepers) help you settle while you can still hear your alarm.
- Dark: in June it is light by around 5 am, and a tent does little to stop it. A flat silk sleep mask in 100 % mulberry silk gives total darkness, folds small and washes at 30 °C.
Walking in to your pitch? Our guide on how to choose trekking poles covers the other piece of kit that makes a loaded walk easier.
Go deeper: the guides in this hub
Temperature and seasons. Ratings, season labels, UK night-time lows and winter camping. Start with sleeping bag temperature ratings, then read about seasons, UK camping temperatures and choosing a winter bag.
Fill and construction. How down and synthetic insulation behave, and what changes when you carry the bag on your back. Start with down vs synthetic, then the backpacking guide.
Shape, size and zips. Cuts, lengths and widths, and what it takes to join two bags. Start with mummy vs rectangular, then the size guide and the guide to zipping bags together.
Van and travel. Sleeping in a campervan, a car or a hostel, with the safety points that go with each. Start with sleeping bag or duvet in a campervan.
Warm and dry nights. Layers, mats, liners and the honest answer to whether a bag can keep rain out: read are sleeping bags waterproof before a wet trip. Start with how to stay warm in a sleeping bag.
Care and storage. Washing, drying, packing and storing, so the bag lofts the same in year five as in year one. Start with how to wash a sleeping bag.
Camping, wild and bivvy sleep. Pitching for a good night, wild camping, bivvies and bothies. Start with how to sleep in a tent.
Care, storage and safety
A sleeping bag stays warm only as long as its insulation can loft. After each trip, air it fully before you pack it away. Wash it only when it needs it: synthetic bags on a gentle cycle without fabric softener, down bags with a down detergent and a long, low tumble dry with tennis balls to break up clumps. Our guides on how to wash a sleeping bag and how to wash a down sleeping bag go step by step.
Between trips, keep it out of its compression sack. A bag left squashed for months may not loft fully again, which is why our guide on how to store a sleeping bag recommends a large, breathable storage bag or a hanger in a dry cupboard. Look after it like this and it will last for many seasons; our guide on how long sleeping bags last explains the signs that it is time to replace one.
Two safety rules apply to any bag. Keep it away from open fires, gas stoves and patio heaters. And never use a fuel-burning appliance to heat a tent or awning: the Camping and Caravanning Club’s safety advice warns that barbecues, stoves and heaters give off carbon monoxide, and that stoves are designed for cooking, not space heating.
Ready to choose?
If you have worked through the five steps, you already know your comfort temperature, your season, your fill, your cut and how you will carry it. For spring-to-autumn camping, festivals and campervan trips, that usually points to a synthetic bag with a comfort rating of around 0 °C. For frosty nights, it points to more insulation, a roomier cut for layers and a careful look at what each temperature figure on the label really means. Compare both of our sleeping bags with this guide open beside you; each comes with a compression sack and a 40-day money-back guarantee.
Pingback: Wild Camping UK: Sleeping Bag and Sleep Kit Guide | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping Mat R-Value Explained: Summer to Winter | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Sleep in Your Car Comfortably (and Safely) | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Pack a Sleeping Bag: Stuff, Don't Roll | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping in a Bivvy Bag: Kit, Warmth and Condensation | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Sleep at a Festival (Tent Survival Guide) | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Difference Between Trekking and Hiking Explained | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping Bag Seasons Explained: 3 Season vs 4 Season | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Can You Zip Two Sleeping Bags Together? | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping Bag Liner Guide: Silk vs Cotton vs Fleece | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping in a Bothy: What to Bring | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping Bag Size Guide for Tall People and Side Sleepers | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Wash a Sleeping Bag: Step by Step | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sleeping Bag Temperature Ratings Explained (Comfort vs Extreme) | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Winter Sleeping Bag Guide: Ratings, Down and Layering | BOLLSEN