⏱️ Estimated reading time: 15 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
The main types are full-length foam insoles (EVA, memory foam or layered foams such as PORON®), full-length gel insoles, 3/4-length insoles, heel cups and heel pads, and firm prescribed orthotics, which are a separate category fitted by a podiatrist. They differ in how much of the foot they cover, how soft or firm they feel and how much shape they give under the arch.
Start with the shoe and the day, not the material. Check whether the factory insole lifts out and how much room the shoe has, then think about what you do in it: long hours standing, a full shift in work boots, a day in trainers, a hill walk or a run. Full-length layered foam suits most everyday shoes; slimmer or partial insoles suit tight shoes; a firm prescribed device is a job for a podiatrist.
For comfort, yes. A good insole adds cushioning, spreads pressure more evenly and gives the foot more shape to rest on than a thin factory liner, so long days on your feet can feel easier. What an over-the-counter insole does not do is treat or cure anything. If pain keeps coming back, the right step is a GP or podiatrist, not a different insole.
In most shoes, yes. A replacement insole is designed to sit where the factory one was. Stacking two insoles fills the shoe, lifts your heel and can crowd your toes. Keep the original, though: laid on top of the new insole, it makes a handy template for trimming.
Buy your normal shoe size first, then trim only to fine-tune. Lay the original insole on top, line up the heels, mark the toe outline and cut a little at a time with sharp scissors, checking the fit in the shoe as you go. It is easy to take more off and impossible to put it back. Our guide on how to size and trim insoles walks through it step by step.
It depends on the material, your weight and how many hours you wear them. BOLLSEN® Insoles are rated for 800 to 1,200 km, roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day. Replace any insole when the cushioning stays flat after you press it or the top layer wears through. More on how to clean insoles and when to replace them in our care guide.
No. A comfort insole is an over-the-counter product for cushioning and everyday support. An orthotic is a device a podiatrist or clinician prescribes after assessing your feet, often made or adjusted for you. A comfort insole is never a substitute for one. We explain the difference between insoles and orthotics in a separate guide.
Most shoes leave the factory with a thin foam liner that is there to finish the shoe, not to carry you through a ten-hour day. Swapping it for a better insole is one of the simplest changes you can make to how a pair of shoes feels. The hard part is choosing, because “insoles” covers everything from a slim gel strip to a firm device made by a podiatrist.
This guide sorts the main types of insoles by what they actually do, matches them to the shoes and days they suit, and covers the practical side: fitting, trimming, breaking in, cleaning and knowing when a pair is finished. If your days are mostly long hours on hard floors, our pick of the best insoles for standing all day goes straight to that.
What an insole actually does
An insole is the layer between your foot and the midsole of the shoe. A good one does three jobs. It cushions, taking some of the edge off each step on hard ground. It spreads pressure, so your weight rests on more of the sole of the foot instead of mainly on the heel and the ball. And it gives the foot some shape to sit on, usually a gentle contour under the arch and a cupped heel that keeps the foot settled in the shoe.
So, do insoles work? For comfort, they do: most people notice the difference on the first long day. But it is worth being honest about the limits. An over-the-counter insole changes how a shoe feels; it does not change the shape of your feet, and it is not a treatment for anything. The shoe matters as much as the insole, too. A cushioned insole in a shoe that is too short, too narrow or worn out will not fix the shoe.
Types of insoles compared
Insoles differ in three ways: how much of the foot they cover, what they are made of, and how firm they are. Material decides most of the feel, and we go deeper into that in gel vs foam insoles. The table below is the quick version.
| Insole type | Coverage | Feel | Support | Typical use | Lifespan signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full-length layered foam (e.g. EVA + PORON®) | Whole foot, heel to toe | Cushioned and springy; each layer does one job | Light to medium shape under the arch, cupped heel | Standing all day, work boots, walking, everyday shoes | Cushioning slowly loses its spring; check the heel for rebound |
| Full-length gel | Whole foot, or gel pads in a foam insole | Soft and squashy straight away | Usually little shape | Shorter wears, roomier shoes | Holds its feel well but adds weight and can feel warm in closed shoes |
| Memory foam | Whole foot | Very soft; moulds to the foot as it warms | Little shape of its own | Casual shoes, short days | Tends to stay pressed down sooner than springier foams |
| EVA foam | Whole foot | Light, fairly firm and springy | Varies; often a moulded arch | Trainers, sports shoes, everyday shoes | Gradually compresses; look for flat spots under the heel and ball |
| 3/4 length | Heel to just behind the toes | Depends on material | Shape under heel and arch only | Snug shoes with little spare room | As for its material; check that it has not slipped forward |
| Heel cup or heel pad | Heel only | Soft cushioning under the heel | Cups the heel; no arch shape | Shoes too snug for a full insole, extra heel cushioning | Small, so wear shows quickly as a flattened centre |
| Prescribed orthotic (separate category) | Varies | Often firm and structured | Shaped for one person after an assessment | Only when a podiatrist or clinician prescribes one; see a podiatrist, not a shop | Reviewed by the clinician who prescribed it |
A few notes on reading it. The feel column is mostly about cushioning, and if softness is your main goal, our guide to cushioned insoles explains why the softest insole on day one is not always the most comfortable in week six. The support column is about shape under the midfoot, from a barely-there contour to a firm shell, and arch support insoles covers what that shape does and does not do in an everyday insole. Partial insoles are a different idea altogether: they add comfort where you need it without filling the shoe, and heel cups vs full-length insoles weighs up the trade-off.
Which type for which day
The most useful way to choose is to start with what you do in the shoes. The same person often needs different things on a Tuesday shift and a Saturday walk.
Standing all day
Standing in one place is harder on the feet than walking, because the same areas take the load for hours. Full-length cushioning with some shape under the arch is the usual answer, and the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety recommends a shock-absorbing cushioned insole for work on hard floors such as concrete. The insole is only part of it: breaks, shifting your weight and footwear that fits all count, and our tips for standing all day at work covers the rest of the routine.
Work boots and safety boots
Work boots tend to be stiff, roomy and worn for long shifts, which suits a full-length layered insole well, provided the boot’s own insole comes out and the toe area still has room once the new one is in. The details, from toe-cap clearance to heat inside a closed boot, are in our guide to insoles for work and safety boots.
Everyday trainers
Trainers are where most of us spend our days, and many come with a removable liner that swaps out easily. A light, full-length foam insole is usually the most comfortable all-day choice. Check for heel slip and a crowded toe box after the swap. See our guide to insoles for trainers for removable and glued-in liners and moving one pair between shoes.
Walking and hiking
On a long walk the insole works with boots, socks and a heavy pack over uneven ground, so cushioning that keeps its spring over many miles and a heel that stays put matter more than first-step softness. Moisture management counts too, because damp feet blister sooner. We cover boot fit and trail days in insoles for walking boots, and if you are planning longer routes, our guide to walking poles for hill days covers the other piece of kit many walkers add.
Running
Running shoes are built around their own midsole, and many runners are happy with the factory insole. A replacement makes sense mainly for comfort, for example when the original has packed flat, and it should be light and slim enough not to change the fit. Our guide to insoles for running looks at when a comfort insole is worth it and when it is not.
Sport
Court shoes, gym trainers and other sports shoes are usually snugger, and movement goes sideways as well as forwards. A slim insole that stays put matters more than extra thickness here, and you should always try it in your own shoes before a match. More in our guide to sports insoles.
Comfort insole or orthotic?
A comfort insole and an orthotic are different products for different jobs. A comfort insole is something you buy off the shelf for cushioning and everyday support. An orthotic (or foot orthosis) is prescribed by a podiatrist or clinician after an assessment, and it is often made or adjusted for one person’s feet. A comfort insole is never a substitute for a device you have been prescribed. We set out the difference between insoles and orthotics in detail.
When to see a GP or podiatrist
Insoles are about comfort. If foot pain keeps coming back, gets worse or stops you doing everyday things, see a GP or a podiatrist rather than trying another insole. The NHS guide to foot pain explains when to get medical help, and the Royal College of Podiatry lets you find a podiatrist near you.
A worked example: how a layered insole is built
Layered insoles combine materials so that each one does a single job well, instead of asking one foam to be soft, springy, supportive and durable at once. Our own BOLLSEN® Insoles are a good example of how such a stack works:
- EVA for flexibility. A light, springy foam that lets the insole bend with the foot as you walk.
- SEBS layer for softness. A soft, rubbery material that gives the insole its cushioned feel underfoot.
- PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption. A dense, resilient foam that takes the sting out of each step. If you want to know how shock-absorbing insoles work, that guide goes into the detail.
- Nylon Pebax shank for support. A thin, firm element under the midfoot that holds the insole’s shape, with a dynamic bridge that adapts to the foot as it moves.
- Breathable top layer. A moisture-managing cover with ventilation holes, so the foot stays drier over a long day.
Put together, that is a full-length comfort insole: cushioned like a foam insole, with more shape than a flat liner, and slim enough for almost any shoe, from trainers to work boots and walking shoes. It is not an orthotic and does not claim to be one. Sizes run from UK 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47).
Getting the fit right
Fit decides whether any insole is comfortable, whatever it is made of. Three habits make most of the difference:
- Take the factory insole out. A replacement sits where the original was. Two layers stacked will crowd the shoe.
- Buy your size, then trim to fine-tune. Choose the insole in your usual shoe size and trim only if the shoe needs it, using the original insole as a template. Cut a little at a time.
- Check the shoe with the insole in. Your heel should sit snugly without lifting, and your toes should still have room to move. If the shoe feels tight, the insole is too full for that shoe.
Shoes that are slightly too big are a common reason to buy insoles in the first place, and they need a slightly different approach. Our guide on how to size and trim insoles covers sizing, thickness and trimming in detail.
Give a new pair a few days. One NHS podiatry service, for example, asks people who are issued prescribed insoles to build up wear time over the first days, starting with up to an hour on day one, in its patient leaflet on insoles and foot orthoses. A comfort insole needs much less adjustment, but the same easy start makes sense: wear them for part of the day at first, then for a full shift once they feel natural.
Care and lifespan
Insoles live in a warm, damp place, so a little care goes a long way. Take them out regularly and let them air-dry fully, away from radiators and direct heat. Washable insoles can be hand-washed gently and left to dry completely before they go back in. Having a second pair to rotate gives each pair time to dry out between days.
Every foam slowly loses its spring. BOLLSEN® Insoles are rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which is roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day; lighter use stretches that further. The signs are the same for any insole: the heel stays flat when you press it, the top layer is worn through or the insole has lost its shape. Our guide on how to clean insoles and when to replace them covers washing, drying and those signs in more detail.
Choosing in three questions
If you take one thing from this guide, make it this order of questions. First, what will you do in the shoes: stand, walk, work, run or play? Second, how much room does the shoe have, and does its insole come out? Third, what feel do you like: soft, springy or firmly held? The answers usually point to one type in the table above.
For most everyday shoes, work boots and walking shoes, that answer is a full-length layered comfort insole. If that is where you land, our layered comfort insole comes in UK sizes 4 to 12.5 with a 40-day money-back guarantee, so you can try it in your own shoes on your own days before you decide.
Pingback: Best Insoles for Standing All Day: A Long-Shift Guide | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Sports Insoles for Gym, Padel, Tennis and Football | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Insoles for Shoes That Are Too Big + How to Trim | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Insoles for Running Shoes: Comfort vs Running-Specific | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Insoles for Walking and Hiking Boots | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Clean Insoles (and When to Replace Them) | BOLLSEN