⏱️ Estimated reading time: 15 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
They can if the shoes are only slightly too big. An insole takes up depth inside the shoe, which stops the heel lifting and the foot sliding forward. As a rule of thumb, that covers about half a size of slack. A shoe that is a full size or more too long, or too wide, needs a different fix.
Take the original insole out and lay it on the new one with the heels lined up. Mark the toe end only, cut a little outside the line, then test the insole in the shoe and trim a little more if it buckles. Never cut the heel cup.
Yes. Buy the insole in your normal shoe size, then trim the toe end to fine-tune the fit for each shoe. A bigger insole does not fill a big shoe better: it buckles at the toe and pushes the heel out of place. Sizes vary between brands, so check the EU size printed inside the shoe as well.
In most shoes, yes. A replacement insole is made to sit where the factory one was. Stacking a new insole on top only works in shoes with real spare room and a thin, flat factory liner. Keep the original either way, because it is the best template for trimming.
It depends on where the slack is. If the heel lifts and the shoe feels roomy over the top of the foot, a thicker full-length insole takes up more of that space. If the shoe is only a touch loose, a slimmer insole keeps the heel low in the heel cup and the ankle clear of the collar.
You bought the shoes in your usual size, or they were in the sale half a size up, and now your heel lifts with every step and your toes slide forward on the stairs. An insole is often the simplest fix for shoes that are slightly too big. It does very little for shoes that are clearly the wrong size.
This guide is the practical one: what an insole can and cannot change, which size and thickness to choose, whether to keep the original insole in, and step-by-step how to trim insoles so they sit flat. If you are still working out what type of insole you need in the first place, start with how to choose insoles.
Can insoles make shoes that are too big fit?
Yes, within limits. A shoe that feels too big usually has too much volume around the foot rather than simply too much length. Your foot sits low, there is a gap over the top of it, and as you walk the heel rises out of the heel counter and the foot slides towards the toe. A full-length insole raises the foot and fills some of that space, so the shoe holds you more firmly at the heel and across the instep.
What an insole can fix:
- Heel slip. Raising the foot brings the heel up to where the heel counter grips it.
- Sliding forward. With less room over the instep, the laces can hold the foot back properly, so the toes stop hitting the front on slopes and stairs.
- A loose, sloppy feel. The shoe stops moving independently of your foot, so there is less rubbing at the heel and toes.
- The end-of-day difference. The Royal College of Podiatry notes that feet can expand by as much as half a size during the day. A shoe that fits well at 6 pm can feel big at 8 am, and an insole takes up some of that morning slack.
What an insole cannot fix:
- Shoes a full size or more too long. The shoe flexes at the wrong point under your foot and the toe box flops. As a rule of thumb, an insole takes up around half a size of slack, not two.
- Shoes that are too wide. An insole adds depth, not width. Your foot will still move from side to side.
Rubbing matters here. The NHS advice on avoiding friction blisters starts with comfortable, well-fitting shoes and wearing new shoes for short periods at first. A shoe that moves on your foot rubs, so getting the fit right is about comfort on a long day, not just about looks.
Should insoles be the same size as your shoes?
Yes. The right approach is simple: buy your size, then trim to fine-tune. Choose the insole in the size you normally wear, then shorten the toe end only as much as each shoe needs. It is tempting to buy a size bigger to fill a big shoe, but that does not work. A longer insole does not add depth; it just curls up at the toe or pushes the heel forward out of the heel cup.
Shoe sizes are not as exact as they look. Shoe size conversion tables, such as the ISO technical specification on converting between shoe sizing systems published in the UK by BSI, start from the length of the foot, but each brand builds its own lasts around those numbers. Two pairs marked UK 8 can differ by several millimetres inside. That is why trimming exists: the size gets you close, the scissors finish the job.
BOLLSEN® Insoles come in 12 sizes. The chart below shows each size exactly as it is sold, with the UK size and the matching EU size, so you can check your UK size before you order.
| UK insole size | EU insole size |
|---|---|
| UK 4 | EU 36 |
| UK 4.5 | EU 37 |
| UK 5.5 | EU 38 |
| UK 6 | EU 39 |
| UK 7 | EU 40 |
| UK 7.5 | EU 41 |
| UK 8.5 | EU 42 |
| UK 9.5 | EU 43 |
| UK 10 | EU 44 |
| UK 11 | EU 45 |
| UK 11.5 | EU 46 |
| UK 12.5 | EU 47 |
If your shoe shows a UK size that is not in the chart, look for the EU size printed on the tongue, the inner side or the sole of the shoe and go by that. Trimming can shorten an insole at the toe, but it can never make one longer. The range covers adult feet only: UK 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47). There are no children’s sizes, so these are not a fix for children’s shoes bought to grow into.
How do you trim insoles to fit?
Trimming is the last step of fitting, not a way of turning one size into another. You need the original insole from the shoe, a pen and a pair of sharp scissors.
- Take out the original insole. Pull the factory insole out of the shoe from the heel end. If it is glued in, see the section on stacking below.
- Use it as the template. The factory insole is the exact shape of the inside of that shoe, so it is the best guide you have.
- Align the heels. Lay the original on top of the new insole and push the two heels together so that the curves match exactly. Hold them firmly so nothing slips.
- Mark the toe end only. Trace around the toe of the original with the pen. Leave the heel and the sides alone; they are shaped to hold your foot.
- Trim a little outside the line. Cut a couple of millimetres outside the mark in one smooth curve. You can always take more off, but you cannot put it back.
- Test it in the shoe. Slide the insole in, push it right back into the heel and check that it lies flat with no curl or ripple at the toe. Then put the shoe on and walk around for a few minutes.
- Trim again if needed. If the toe still buckles or presses against the front of the shoe, take off another millimetre or two and test again. Match the second insole to the first, so the pair is the same.
One rule above all: never cut the heel cup. The back of a full-length insole is shaped to cradle the heel, and cutting it removes the part that holds your foot in place. If an insole only fits after cutting at the heel, it is the wrong size for that shoe.
If you plan to move one pair between several shoes, trim to the shortest of them. An insole that is a millimetre short in a roomier shoe is fine. One that buckles in a tighter shoe is not.
Thick or thin insoles for shoes that are a bit big?
Match the thickness to where the slack actually is.
- The heel lifts and there is space over the top of the foot. This is a volume problem, and a thicker full-length insole is the right answer. It takes up the most room and gives the laces something to work against.
- The shoe is only a touch loose. A slimmer insole is enough. Going too thick here lifts the heel above the top of the heel counter, so the collar sits lower around your ankle and the heel can slip out again.
- Only the toe end feels long. Thickness will not help much. The shoe is probably too long, and the section on what an insole cannot fix applies.
Coverage matters as much as thickness. A full-length insole raises the whole foot evenly, from heel to toe. Partial inserts change the fit in one area only, which is a different job, and our comparison of 3/4 or full-length insoles goes through when each makes sense. In a shoe that is too big all over, full-length is the better choice.
BOLLSEN® Insoles are a full-length comfort insole built in layers: an EVA layer for flexibility, a soft SEBS layer, PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption, a Nylon Pebax shank for support and a breathable, moisture-managing top layer with ventilation holes. That gives them enough body to take up slack in a roomy shoe while staying slim enough for almost any shoe. How soft that feels underfoot is covered in our guide to cushioned insoles.
Should you remove the original insole or stack them?
In most shoes, take the original out. A replacement insole is made to sit on the base of the shoe, where the factory insole was. Put it on top of the original instead and two things happen: the foot rises further than you planned, and the two layers can slide against each other as you walk.
Stacking does have a place. If the shoe is clearly roomy and the factory insole is thin and flat, or glued in so it cannot come out, a new insole on top can take up the extra space. Check three things before you settle on it:
- The new insole lies flat on top of the old one and does not move when you push it forward with your hand.
- Your heel still sits inside the heel counter rather than above it.
- Your toes have room to move and do not press against the top of the shoe.
If any of those fail, take the factory insole out. If it cannot come out, that shoe is not a good home for a second layer. The same logic applies whatever the shoe: our guide to insoles for trainers covers removable and glued-in factory insoles in more detail, and boots with a lot of depth are covered in the best insoles for work boots.
What about wide feet?
Wide feet and big shoes often go together. If standard fittings are too narrow, it is common to buy a longer shoe to get the width, and then there is spare length at the toe. An insole can help with part of that. It takes up depth and stops the heel slipping, but it cannot take away the extra length in front of your toes.
Width and depth both matter. The Royal College of Podiatry’s advice on choosing footwear points out that width and depth are an important part of fit and comfort, and suggests trying shoes on with the socks you will wear. For wide feet, the lasting answer is a shoe in a wide fitting in your own length. Inside it, choose a slimmer insole, because a thick one makes a wide toe box feel tight over the top of the toes.
Other ways to take up a little slack
An insole works best together with a few small adjustments. Try these before you decide a pair of shoes is beyond saving:
- Lace for the heel. Use the extra top eyelet, if your shoes have one, to tie a heel lock. It pulls the heel back into the heel counter without overtightening across the toes.
- Check your socks. A slightly thicker sock takes up a little room and can reduce rubbing. Fit the shoes with the socks you will actually wear in them.
- Give new insoles a few short wears. Wear them around the house first, then for a few hours, then for a full day.
If a pair is still a full size out after all of that, an insole will not save it. Return or exchange the shoes if you can, and use the insole in a pair that fits. If your feet are sore or uncomfortable even in shoes that fit, it is worth getting them looked at: the Royal College of Podiatry can help you find a podiatrist near you.
Living with your trimmed insoles
Once the fit is right, push the heel of the insole right back each time you put it in, so it sits flat. BOLLSEN® Insoles are washable and removable, so you can take them out to dry after a long day and move them between shoes of the same size. They are rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which is roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day, and lighter use stretches that further. Our guide on how to clean insoles and when to replace them covers the care side.
The real test is a normal week in your own shoes. Every pair comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, which is plenty of time to trim them, try them in the shoes that feel too big and see whether the heel stays put.
Pingback: Types of Insoles: How to Choose the Right Pair | BOLLSEN
Pingback: How to Clean Insoles (and When to Replace Them) | BOLLSEN