⏱️ Estimated reading time: 15 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
The most comfortable insole is the one that still feels good at the end of a long day and after a few months of wear, not just in the first minute. In practice that usually means a soft surface over a resilient foam that springs back, in a thickness that suits your shoe and your size.
Every step squeezes the foam. Many soft foams never fully recover their thickness, and that permanent loss is called compression set. Cheap memory foam is the classic case: it feels plush at first, then moulds to the foot and stays pressed down, so the cushioning under the heel and the ball of the foot gets thinner.
No. A very thick or very soft insole can crowd the shoe, lift your heel out of the heel cup and squash right through under load, which feels less stable and not more comfortable. A moderate layer of foam that rebounds well usually beats a deep layer that bottoms out.
Cushioning is about softness and how impact is absorbed. Support is about shape and structure under the arch and midfoot. If you stand or walk for hours, you will usually be happiest with a bit of both: a soft top layer for comfort and a stable base, so the insole does not fold or twist under your weight.
It depends on the materials and on how hard you use them. Basic memory foam can feel noticeably flatter within weeks. Our layered insole is rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which is roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day. Replace any insole once it looks thin or no longer springs back.
Almost every insole on a shop shelf feels soft when you press it with your thumb. That test tells you very little. The real questions are how it feels after eight hours on a shop floor or a warehouse concrete slab, and whether it still feels the same three months later.
This guide looks at cushioning on its own: what makes an insole feel comfortable, why so many soft insoles go flat, and how to judge “comfiest” in a way that lasts. If you are still working out which kind of insole suits your shoes in the first place, start with how to choose insoles, then come back here for the detail on softness.
Softness, rebound and bottoming out
“Cushioned” gets used as if it were one property. It is really three, and an insole can be good at one and poor at another.
- Softness is how easily the surface gives when your foot lands. It is what you feel in the shop and in the first few steps.
- Rebound is how quickly and how fully the material springs back after each step. Good rebound means the foam is ready for the next step instead of still recovering from the last one.
- Bottoming out is what happens when a soft layer is pressed so far that there is nothing left to give. At that point your heel is effectively standing on the shoe’s sole, and the soft feel is gone.
A thin, very soft foam can feel lovely when you try it on and then bottom out under the heel as soon as you walk briskly or carry something heavy. A slightly firmer foam with strong rebound may feel less dramatic at first but keeps giving the same amount of cushioning step after step. That second quality, keeping its thickness and spring, is the one that decides whether an insole is still comfortable at 5 pm. The physics of how a foam takes the sting out of each heel strike is a topic of its own, covered in our guide to how shock absorption works in an insole.
Why soft insoles go flat
Foam is a network of tiny cells filled with air. When you step down, the cells compress; when you lift your foot, they should recover. Over thousands of steps, some cell walls bend, tear or set in their squashed shape. The foam ends up thinner than it started, and engineers measure that lost thickness as compression set.
Memory foam is the best-known example. It is popular because it feels so plush in the shop, but a 2019 article from Rogers Corporation on footwear materials notes that typical memory foams attract buyers with initial comfort and then collapse quickly because of their low resistance to compression set. The same article describes foams that permanently mould to the shape of the foot after a short period of use, which leaves less cushioning under the heel and the ball of the foot, exactly where you want it most.
Two other things add to the strain. Rogers lists perspiration and the rising temperature inside a shoe among the stresses an underfoot foam has to cope with, and long hours of standing keep the same patch of foam under load with little time to recover. That is why an insole that feels fine for a short walk can feel flat after a week of full shifts.
It is worth saying that Rogers makes PORON®, so it has an interest in comparing other foams unfavourably. Its claims match what most people notice with cheap soft insoles, though: they look and feel thinner after a few weeks, and you can often see a permanent dent where the heel sits.
How cushioning types feel over time
The table below sums up how the common cushioning materials tend to feel at three moments that matter: the first step, the end of a long day and after about three months of regular wear. It is a guide to typical behaviour rather than a lab ranking, and a lot depends on the thickness and quality of each foam. For a full side-by-side of the materials themselves, see our guide with gel vs foam insoles compared.
| Cushioning type | First-step feel | After 8 hours | After 3 months |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memory foam | Very soft, sinks in and moulds to the foot | Often warm, and may have pressed down under the heel and ball of the foot | Frequently thinner, with a lasting footprint dent and less spring |
| Gel | Dense and cool, firmer than it looks | Keeps its shape, but spreads pressure less than a soft foam | Holds its thickness well; the cover can wear, and the insole stays heavy |
| EVA foam on its own | Light and springy | Comfortable, with some loss of spring in warm shoes | Tends to firm up and take on the shape of the foot |
| SEBS (soft elastomer layer) | Soft and rubbery underfoot | Stays elastic; as a thin layer it relies on the foam beneath it for depth | Keeps its surface feel when it sits over a resilient foam |
| PORON® urethane foam | Cushioned, with a quick spring back | Built to keep rebounding under repeated load | Designed to resist compression set, so it keeps more of its thickness |
The EVA, gel and polyurethane rows broadly follow a materials presentation Rogers gave to the footwear industry association FDRA on underfoot cushioning, which compared samples before and after accelerated ageing designed to simulate a month of wear. In those tests, EVA moulded to the foot and felt firmer but less supportive after a short period, commodity polyurethane lost some of its load-bearing support, and gel kept its shape but offered limited conformability.
The “after 8 hours” column is where people who stand at work feel the difference most. If that is your situation, our guide to the best insoles for standing all day goes through the shoe, sock and insole choices for long shifts.
What “comfiest” should actually mean
People shopping for the “comfiest insoles” usually judge comfort in the worst possible way: a quick squeeze in the hand or thirty seconds standing in a shop. A fairer test has three stages.
- The first step. Put the insoles in the shoes you actually wear, with the socks you actually wear. The heel should sit in the insole’s heel area, your toes should not feel squashed against the top of the shoe, and nothing should rub. Softness here is pleasant, but it is the least important of the three tests.
- The end of the day. Wear them through a normal working day or a long walk. Notice how your feet feel at the end compared with the original insole. Does the heel still feel cushioned, or does it feel like you are standing on the sole? Are your feet hotter than usual?
- After a few weeks. Take the insoles out and look at them. A deep heel dent, a shiny compressed patch under the ball of the foot or a top cover that has started to bunch are all signs the cushioning is going. Press the heel area with your thumb: it should still spring back.
An insole that passes all three is genuinely comfortable. One that only passes the first is just soft.
Is more cushioning always better?
More is not automatically better, for three practical reasons.
Room in the shoe. Every millimetre of insole lifts your foot inside the shoe. Too much, and the heel starts to slip out of the heel cup, the toes press against the top of the toe box and laces have to be loosened to compensate. Always take the shoe’s original insole out before you fit a new full-length one, so you are replacing a layer rather than stacking two.
Stability. A very soft, very deep layer lets the foot sink and roll a little with every step. Some people like that feeling for short spells; over a long day many find it tiring and prefer something that feels more planted.
Cushioning is not the same as support. Cushioning softens how the foot lands. Support comes from the shape and the stiffer parts of an insole, such as a contoured heel area or a shank under the midfoot, which stop it folding or twisting under load. For most people who are on their feet all day, the comfortable middle ground is a soft, resilient layer for cushioning sitting on a structured base for support. If you want to understand the support side in more depth, our guide to arch support insoles explains how much structure an everyday comfort insole should have.
When cushioning is not the answer
A cushioned insole is a comfort product. It can make long days on your feet more pleasant, but it is not a treatment for anything, and it is not a substitute for an insole prescribed by a podiatrist. Foot pain that keeps coming back, gets worse or does not settle after a change of shoes is a reason to get advice: the NHS guidance on foot pain explains when to see a GP. You can also find an HCPC-registered podiatrist through the Royal College of Podiatry.
How a layered insole stays comfortable
One way around the “soft at first, flat later” problem is to stop asking one foam to do every job. A layered insole puts each material where it works best. Our own BOLLSEN® Insoles, with a SEBS soft layer over PORON® ShockPad, are built like this:
- Breathable top layer that manages moisture, with ventilation holes, so the surface stays more comfortable as feet warm up through the day.
- SEBS layer for softness, which gives the first-step feel.
- PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption. This is the layer that has to keep its thickness, and PORON® urethane is designed to resist compression set.
- EVA base for flexibility, so the insole bends with the shoe instead of fighting it.
- Nylon Pebax shank with a dynamic midfoot bridge that adapts to the foot, for support under the midfoot.
Fit matters as much as materials. Buy your usual size (they run from UK 4 to 12.5, which is EU 36 to 47), then trim the toe end to fine-tune the fit in each pair of shoes. The insoles are removable, washable and can be moved between work shoes, trainers and walking shoes, so one pair can follow you through the week.
Breaking in a new pair
Any new insole changes how your foot sits in a familiar shoe, even a soft one. A short settling-in period makes the change easier:
- Take the old insole out first and use it as a template if you need to trim.
- Wear the new pair for a few hours on the first days, then build up to a full day.
- Check the fit after the first long wear. If the heel slips or the toes feel crowded, a little more trimming or a different pair of shoes usually sorts it out.
- Give it a week of normal use before you judge the end-of-day comfort.
How long cushioning lasts and when to replace it
No foam lasts forever. How long an insole stays comfortable depends on the material, your weight, how many hours a day you wear it and how warm your shoes get. Basic memory foam can feel noticeably flatter within weeks of daily use. Our layered insole is rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which works out at roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day. Lighter use stretches that further.
Whatever you wear, these are the signs that it is time for a new pair:
- A deep dent under the heel that does not recover overnight.
- The heel area no longer springs back when you press it.
- The top cover is worn through, bunching or peeling.
- Your feet feel at the end of the day the way they did before you started using the insoles.
Washing helps the top layer stay fresh, and letting insoles air-dry fully between long wears gives the foam time to recover. If you work long shifts, two pairs used in rotation is a simple way to give each one that recovery time.
The best way to find out whether a cushioned insole is right for you is to wear it in your own shoes, on your own days. Every pair of BOLLSEN® Insoles comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, which is long enough to run all three comfort tests above.
Pingback: Best Insoles for Standing All Day: A Long-Shift Guide | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Gel vs Foam Insoles: Which Material Is Better? | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Insoles for Walking and Hiking Boots | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Arch Support Insoles: How Much Support Do You Need? | BOLLSEN