Insoles for Trainers: How to Upgrade the Insole in Your Everyday Shoes

⏱️ Estimated reading time: 14 min

Short answerMost trainers take a replacement insole well. Check whether the factory insole lifts out, take it out rather than stacking, and watch for heel slip or a crowded toe box after the swap. Buy your size and trim only to fine-tune. A removable pair can move between similar shoes, and a light layered foam suits everyday trainers well.
Hands sliding a plain grey insole into a white trainer on a light oak hallway floor, the original insole beside it
On this page: Overview
    Summarize with AI

    Key Takeaways

    Yes. Most trainers take an aftermarket insole well, especially if the factory insole lifts out. Take the original out, put the new pair in its place and check that your heel still sits snugly and your toes have room to move. If the trainer feels tight with the new insole in, it is too full and needs a different approach.

    In most cases, yes. A replacement insole is designed to sit where the factory one was, not on top of it. Stacking two insoles fills the shoe, lifts your heel towards the top of the heel counter and can leave your toes pressed against the upper. Keep the original, though: it makes a handy template for trimming.

    Some trainers have a thin lining glued or stitched to the base instead of a loose insole. If it is only lightly glued, it may peel out with care. If it is firmly fixed, an extra insole goes on top, which only works in trainers with spare room. In a snug, low trainer, a different pair of shoes is usually the better home for the insole.

    Yes, as long as the shoes are a similar size and shape inside and both have a removable insole. Trim the pair to the tighter of the two shoes, since an insole that is slightly short sits better than one that buckles at the toe. Moving them takes a few seconds once you have done it once.

    Gel can feel pleasantly soft in a trainer, but it can be heavier than foam and some people find it warm in a closed shoe. For everyday trainers, a light layered foam insole is often the more comfortable all-day choice. The main thing is that the insole suits the room in your shoe, whatever it is made of.

    Trainers are the shoes most of us actually live in. They go on for the school run, the commute, a day in town and the walk home, and many of them come with a thin, flat factory insole that was never meant to carry that much of your day. Swapping that insole for a better one is one of the cheapest ways to change how a pair of trainers feels, provided it fits the shoe properly once it is in.

    This guide covers everyday trainers and walking shoes: how to tell whether the factory insole comes out, what changes inside the shoe after the swap, and how to make one pair of insoles work across several shoes. If you are still deciding what kind of insole you need in the first place, start with how to choose insoles. Trainers you mainly run in are a separate question, with their own priorities on weight and drop, and our guide to insoles for running shoes covers them.

    Removable or glued in: how to check your trainers

    Before you buy anything, find out what is already in the shoe. It takes a minute and decides how the rest of the swap goes.

    1. Take the laces out of the top two or three eyelets so you can open the shoe wide.
    2. Reach in to the heel and lift the edge of the insole with a fingertip.
    3. If it peels up easily and comes out in one piece, it is a removable insole (often called a sockliner). This is the easy case.
    4. If it resists, feels bonded all the way along, or you can see stitching around the edge, it is glued or stitched in.

    Most running-style and walking-style trainers have a removable insole. Fashion trainers, slip-ons and very light knitted shoes are where you more often find a thin lining that is fixed to the base. Some of those have a light spot of glue only under the heel and come out cleanly with a slow, steady pull. Do not force it: if the lining tears or the foam underneath starts to come away, stop and treat the shoe as a glued-in pair.

    With a glued-in lining you have two options. If the trainer has room to spare, you can place a slim insole on top and check the fit as described below. If the trainer is already snug, an extra layer will crowd your foot, and the insole will do more good in a different pair.

    Trainers with removable insoles: what to look for

    Once the factory insole is out, the replacement has to do two jobs at once: feel better under your foot and fit the space it is going into. A thick, sculpted insole might feel great in your hand and still be wrong for a low-profile trainer.

    • Thickness that matches the shoe. Everyday trainers have less spare depth than boots. A slim insole that sits close to the height of the factory one keeps the fit you chose the trainer for.
    • Cushioning that keeps its spring. The first-step feel matters less than how the insole feels at the end of a long day on pavements and shop floors. Our guide to cushioned insoles explains why.
    • Some structure under the midfoot. A light shank stops the insole from folding or twisting, so it stays flat and in place in a soft shoe. More on that in arch support insoles.
    • A breathable top. Trainers get warm, and a top layer that moves moisture away keeps the insole more pleasant over a full day.
    • The right size. Buy the size you wear, then trim only to fine-tune the fit at the toe.

    BOLLSEN® Insoles, slim enough for most trainers, are built in layers for exactly this kind of everyday wear: an EVA layer for flexibility, a soft SEBS layer, PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption, a Nylon Pebax shank for support and a breathable, moisture-managing top layer with ventilation holes. A dynamic bridge under the midfoot adapts to the foot as it moves. They come in UK sizes 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47). Slim enough for almost any shoe is the honest description, rather than a promise that they fit every one, so try them in your own trainers before you decide.

    Volume and heel slip after the swap

    The insole is part of the inside of the shoe. Change it, and you change how much room your foot has, and the first place you notice it is usually the heel.

    If the new insole is thicker than the old one, your foot sits higher. Your heel moves up towards the top edge of the heel counter, the collar may sit lower around your ankle and the toe box can feel shallower. Walk around the house for ten minutes. If your heel lifts out of the back of the shoe with each step, or your toes press against the upper, the shoe is too full.

    If the new insole is thinner, the shoe feels roomier and your foot may slide forward on stairs and slopes. Re-lacing usually sorts this out: tighten the laces across the instep and use the extra top eyelet, if your trainers have one, for a heel lock.

    A little movement at the heel is what rubs, and rubbing is what turns into blisters on a long walk. The NHS advice on preventing friction blisters starts with comfortable, well-fitting shoes and wearing new shoes for short periods until they are comfortable. Treat freshly fitted insoles the same way: a couple of shorter wears first, then a full day.

    How to trim insoles for trainers

    Trimming is about fine-tuning, not about turning one size into another. Start from your own shoe size and only take off what the shoe asks for.

    1. Put the factory insole on top of the new one, lining up the heels.
    2. Mark the outline at the toe with a pen. Most trainers only need a small change at the front, if any.
    3. Cut a little outside the line with sharp scissors, in one smooth curve.
    4. Slide the insole in, push it right back into the heel and check that it lies flat with no curl at the toe.
    5. If it still buckles, trim a millimetre or two more and try again.

    If you plan to move the pair between several shoes, trim to the shortest one and stop as soon as the insole sits flat. There is a fuller walk-through in our guide on how to trim insoles.

    Everyday walking shoes

    Plenty of people never think of their walking shoes as sports kit, yet they cover more miles in them than in anything else. The NHS says in its guide to walking for health that any shoes or trainers that are comfortable, give adequate support and do not cause blisters will do for regular walking. That is a useful test for an insole swap too: the right insole should leave the shoe more comfortable at the end of the walk, not just in the first few steps.

    Everyday walking shoes and lightweight walking trainers usually have a removable insole and a little more depth than a casual trainer, which makes them an easy fit. Walk your usual route, whether that is the commute, the dog walk or a lap of the park, and pay attention to the last half hour rather than the first five minutes. If your day is more standing than walking, our pick of the best insoles for standing all day is the better starting point. For heavier boots on trails and hills, the volume, moisture and cushioning questions are different enough to have their own guide on insoles for walking boots.

    Comfort in a shoe depends on more than the insole, and no insole can make up for shoes that do not fit. If your feet keep hurting despite well-fitting shoes, it is worth getting them looked at: the Royal College of Podiatry can help you find a podiatrist near you.

    Moving one pair between shoes

    One good pair of insoles does not have to live in one pair of shoes. Because they are removable, you can move them from your work trainers to your weekend ones in a few seconds. A few habits make that easier:

    • Match the shoes roughly. Shoes in the same size with a similar shape inside take the same insole well. A narrow fashion trainer and a roomy walking shoe may need two different pairs.
    • Trim for the tightest shoe. An insole that is a touch short in the roomier shoe is fine. One that curls up at the toe in the tighter shoe is not.
    • Keep the factory insoles. Store each original insole with its shoe, so you can put it back if you wear that pair without the upgrade.
    • Push the heel home every time. After each move, slide the insole right back so it sits flat in the heel cup before you lace up.

    Many people end up with one pair in their everyday trainers and a second pair for work shoes or walking shoes, so nothing needs moving on a busy morning. For boots you wear on site all day, see our guide to the best insoles for work boots. Either way works: the insole is the same, only the routine changes.

    Gel insoles for trainers

    Gel is the material many people picture first when they think of a comfort insole, and in a trainer it can feel soft and cushioned straight away. It can also be heavier than foam, and some people find it warm in a closed shoe, which matters more in a low trainer than in a roomy boot. Layered foams such as PORON® ShockPad aim for the same soft landing with less weight, and for many people they are the more comfortable choice over a long day in trainers. We compare the materials side by side in gel vs foam insoles.

    Keeping them fresh and knowing when to replace them

    Trainers get worn in all weathers and often without much rest between days, so the insoles need a little care. Take them out now and then and let them air-dry fully, away from radiators and direct heat. Ours are washable, so give them a gentle wash now and then and let them dry completely before they go back into the shoe.

    Even good foam slowly loses its spring. BOLLSEN® Insoles are rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which is roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day. Lighter use stretches that further. Replace a pair when the heel no longer springs back when you press it, the top layer is worn through or your feet feel at the end of the day the way they did before the swap.

    Trying them in your own trainers

    The only test that counts is a normal day in your own shoes. Every pair of BOLLSEN® Insoles comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, which is plenty of time to try them in your trainers, your walking shoes and whatever else you wear most. If you also want a pair for the gym or the court, where shoes are tighter and movement goes sideways, our guide to sports insoles covers what changes there.

    4 thoughts on “Insoles for Trainers: How to Upgrade the Insole in Your Everyday Shoes”

    1. Pingback: Gel vs Foam Insoles: Which Material Is Better? | BOLLSEN

    2. Pingback: Insoles for Walking and Hiking Boots | BOLLSEN

    3. Pingback: Insoles for Running Shoes: Comfort vs Running-Specific | BOLLSEN

    4. Pingback: Sports Insoles for Gym, Padel, Tennis and Football | BOLLSEN

    Comments are closed.