⏱️ Estimated reading time: 12 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
A comfort insole is an over-the-counter product you choose yourself to make your shoes feel more cushioned and supportive. An orthotic (also called a foot orthosis) is a device a podiatrist or orthotist recommends or prescribes after assessing your feet, to do a specific job for that person. One is about comfort and fit; the other is part of clinical care.
No. BOLLSEN® Insoles are a full-length, over-the-counter comfort insole made in standard sizes. They are not an orthotic, they are not made to measure, and they are not a substitute for a device a clinician has prescribed. Their job is comfort, cushioning and support in everyday, work and sports shoes.
You do not need a prescription to buy an insole in a shop. A prescribed orthotic is different: it comes after an assessment by a podiatrist or orthotist, either through NHS podiatry (via a GP referral or, in many areas, self-referral) or from a private HCPC-registered podiatrist, who decides whether a device is needed at all.
The NHS advises seeing a GP when foot pain stops someone doing normal activities, gets worse or keeps coming back, or has not improved after two weeks of home care. Tingling, loss of feeling or weakness in the foot, foot pain in someone with diabetes, and a possible injury such as a broken bone also need professional advice.
Only if they feel comfortable. A comfort insole is not a treatment, so it should never be a reason to put off an appointment. Once a podiatrist has seen you, follow their advice: if they prescribe a device or tell you which footwear to use, that advice comes first.
Insoles and orthotics look alike. Both sit inside the shoe, both are shaped to the foot, and shops often display them on the same shelf. They are not the same thing, though, and mixing them up can lead to buying the wrong product or skipping help that is actually needed.
The short answer: a comfort insole is an over-the-counter product you pick yourself, for comfort and cushioning. An orthotic is a device that a podiatrist or orthotist recommends or prescribes after an assessment. This guide sets the two side by side, explains how people in the UK get to see a podiatrist, and lists the signs the NHS says should prompt professional advice. If you are comparing comfort insoles with each other rather than with orthotics, our guides on how to choose insoles and how insole materials compare go deeper.
Insoles vs orthotics: how do they compare?
There are really three things people mean when they talk about insoles and orthotics. The table sets them out.
| Comfort insole | Off-the-shelf “orthotic-style” insole | Custom or prescribed orthotic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Comfort, cushioning, shock absorption and a supportive feel in everyday, work and sports shoes | A firmer, more structured feel; still a general product, not matched to one person | A specific job decided by a clinician for one person, often alongside exercises or footwear advice |
| Who decides | You, based on your shoes and how they feel | You, based on the product description | A podiatrist or orthotist, after an assessment |
| Fitting | Standard sizes; buy your size, trim if the design allows | Standard sizes and shapes; little or no adjustment | Made from a cast or scan, or a stock device selected and adjusted by the clinician, with a wearing-in plan and review |
| Typical UK route | Shop or online | Shop, pharmacy or online | NHS podiatry (GP referral or, in many areas, self-referral) or a private HCPC-registered podiatrist |
Heel-only inserts such as heel cups and heel pads are a fourth, simpler group; our guide to heel cups vs full-length insoles compares them with full-length designs.
What is a comfort insole for?
A comfort insole replaces or sits over the thin foam insert most shoes come with. It is made in standard sizes and shapes, and you choose it yourself based on how your shoes feel and how you use them. The job is practical:
- Cushioning. Softer layers under the heel and forefoot make hard floors and long days on your feet feel more comfortable.
- Shock absorption. Impact-absorbing foam takes some of the jolt out of each step on hard surfaces.
- Support and fit. A contoured shape under the midfoot gives the foot a defined place to sit, so it moves around less in the shoe.
That is the whole remit. A comfort insole can make a pair of shoes feel better for standing, walking or work, and many people simply like the feel. It is not designed to change how a foot is built or how it moves. If you want to know more about the contour under the midfoot, our guide on what arch support in a comfort insole does explains how much support suits which shoes.
What is an orthotic?
An orthotic, or foot orthosis, belongs to a different category. A patient information leaflet from the Dudley Group NHS Foundation Trust explains that orthoses are commonly called insoles, and that the devices it issues are prescribed by a podiatrist based on the findings of an assessment. That is the key difference: someone qualified has looked at the person’s feet first and decided what the device should do.
A few things follow from that:
- It comes after an assessment. A podiatrist or orthotist examines the feet, asks about symptoms and activity, and only then decides whether an orthotic is the right step. Often it is used alongside other advice, such as exercises or footwear changes.
- It is specified for one person. Some orthotics are made from a cast or scan of the foot; others are stock devices that a clinician selects and adjusts. Either way, the choice is clinical.
- It comes with instructions. NHS leaflets typically describe a gradual wearing-in period and ask patients to report back if anything feels wrong, so the device can be reviewed.
Podiatrists and orthotists are regulated professions in the UK. The Health and Care Professions Council lists “podiatrist”, “chiropodist” and “orthotist” as protected titles, which means only people on its register can use them.
What about off-the-shelf “orthotic-style” insoles?
Between the two sits a grey area: firmer, more contoured insoles sold in shops and online, often with clinical-sounding names. They are still over-the-counter products in standard sizes, chosen by the buyer without an assessment. A label on the box is not a prescription, and no shop insole can know what a podiatrist would find after examining someone’s feet.
That does not make them bad products. Some people like a firmer, more structured feel in stiff shoes. But it helps to judge them as what they are, a comfort and fit choice, and to treat persistent or worsening foot problems as a reason to get advice rather than a reason to buy a firmer insole.
How do you see a podiatrist in the UK?
There are two main routes, and the right one depends on the situation and the local service.
- Through the NHS. A GP can assess foot pain and refer to NHS podiatry where needed. In many areas, people can also refer themselves to the local NHS podiatry service; the service sets its own criteria for who it sees, so check your local NHS trust’s podiatry page.
- Privately. A private podiatrist can usually see you without a referral. The Royal College of Podiatry has a tool to find a podiatrist near you, and you can confirm that anyone using the title is registered on the HCPC register.
For an urgent problem, such as a suspected broken bone, severe pain or being unable to walk, the NHS advises contacting NHS 111 rather than waiting for a routine appointment.
When should you see a podiatrist or GP?
Signs that call for professional advice
Insoles of any kind are not a substitute for professional advice. The NHS page on pain in the bottom of the foot advises seeing a GP when:
- foot pain stops someone doing their normal activities
- the pain is getting worse or keeps coming back
- it has not improved after two weeks of looking after it at home
- there is tingling or loss of feeling in the foot, or the feet feel weak
- a person with diabetes has foot pain, because foot problems can be more serious with diabetes
After an injury, such as a suspected broken bone, or with severe pain or being unable to walk, the NHS advises contacting NHS 111. A GP can refer on to podiatry where needed, or a private HCPC-registered podiatrist can assess the feet directly.
If a podiatrist does recommend an orthotic, it replaces guesswork with a device chosen for that person. If they do not, they can still explain what kind of footwear or comfort insole makes sense, which is useful information before buying anything.
Can you wear comfort insoles while waiting for an appointment?
Only if they feel comfortable, and only as a comfort measure. A comfort insole is not a treatment and should never be a reason to delay seeing someone. If anything feels worse after changing insoles, take them out.
Once a podiatrist has seen you, their advice comes first. If they prescribe an orthotic, use it as instructed and ask them whether, and when, a comfort insole has a place in your other shoes.
Where do BOLLSEN® Insoles fit?
To be clear about our own product: BOLLSEN® Insoles are a comfort insole, not an orthotic. They are made in standard sizes, they are not made to measure, and they are never a substitute for a prescribed device. They sit in the first column of the table above.
What they are designed for is comfort in everyday, work and sports shoes, layer by layer:
- EVA for flexibility, so the insole moves with the shoe.
- SEBS for softness underfoot.
- PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption.
- A Nylon Pebax shank for support, with a dynamic midfoot bridge that adapts to the foot.
- A breathable, moisture-managing top layer with ventilation holes.
BOLLSEN® Insoles, an over-the-counter comfort insole, come in UK sizes 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47). Buy your size, then trim to fine-tune the fit in a particular shoe. They are removable and washable, swap between shoe types and last around 800 to 1,200 km, roughly 8 to 10 months for a person weighing 100 kg who is on their feet 8 hours a day. Every pair comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, so there is time to try them in your own shoes, on your own routine.
In short: choose a comfort insole for comfort, and leave orthotics to the professionals who prescribe them.