⏱️ Estimated reading time: 14 min

On this page: Overview
Key Takeaways
Neither wins on every count. Gel is dense, firm and keeps its shape, but it is heavy and does not breathe. Foams are lighter and softer, but cheap ones flatten. A good resilient foam, or a layered insole that combines a soft layer with a foam that resists flattening, usually gives the best balance for all-day wear.
Gel usually keeps its thickness longer, because it behaves almost like a solid and springs back to the same shape. Memory foam is designed to sink and mould, and many memory foams never fully recover, so they tend to look and feel flatter sooner. With gel, the usual sign of age is a worn or split cover rather than lost thickness.
PORON® is a family of microcellular polyurethane foams made by Rogers Corporation, a US materials company. Its open cells are tiny, around 100 microns on average according to Rogers, and the material is engineered to resist compression set, which means it keeps more of its original thickness after repeated squashing. PORON® ShockPad is the grade made for impact absorption.
Memory foam is a slow-recovery polyurethane that softens with warmth and moulds to the foot. That is what makes it feel plush, but many memory foams have low resistance to compression set: after weeks of body weight, warmth and sweat, the cells stay partly crushed. The result is a permanent footprint and less foam under the heel and the ball of the foot.
They often feel cool when you first put them on, because gel is dense and draws warmth away from the skin. Gel does not let air or moisture through, though, so in a closed shoe over a long day many people find gel insoles warm and a little clammy. Open-cell foams and perforated top covers usually feel fresher by the afternoon.
Gel vs foam insoles in short: gel is firm, heavy and holds its shape but does not breathe; memory foam is the softest at first but tends to flatten; EVA is light and springy but moulds to the foot over time; SEBS adds a soft, rubbery layer; and PORON® urethane is built to keep its thickness. Many good insoles layer two or more of them.
Insole packaging rarely tells you much beyond “gel” or “memory foam”, and a squeeze in the shop tells you even less. What matters is how each material feels after a full day in the shoe and after a few months of wear. This guide compares the five materials you meet most often, side by side, and explains why so many insoles now combine them. If you have not yet decided what kind of insole you need for your shoes, start with how to choose insoles and come back here for the material detail.
The five common insole materials at a glance
The table below compares gel, memory foam, EVA, SEBS and PORON® urethane on the five things that decide how an insole lives with you: how it feels underfoot, how much it weighs, how warm it gets in a closed shoe, how well it resists flattening, and what tends to tell you it is worn out. It describes typical behaviour, not a lab ranking. Thickness, density and the quality of each formulation make a big difference within every category.
| Material | Feel underfoot | Weight | Heat in a closed shoe | Compression set (flattening) | Typical lifespan signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gel | Dense and firm, with a slightly bouncy, “solid” feel; conforms little to the foot | Heaviest of the five | Cool to the touch at first; does not breathe, so it can feel warm and clammy later in the day | Very low: gel keeps its shape under load | Cover wears, peels or splits before the gel itself thins |
| Memory foam | Very soft, slow to recover; sinks in and moulds to the foot | Light to moderate | Tends to hold warmth, and it softens further as it warms up | Often high: many memory foams stay partly crushed | A lasting footprint and a thin, hard patch under the heel |
| EVA | Light and springy when new; firmer and closer to the foot’s shape after a while | Lightest of the five | Closed cells do not soak up sweat; feels fairly neutral | Moderate: EVA gradually takes the shape of the foot | Firmer, less lively feel and a visible foot imprint |
| SEBS | Soft, rubbery and elastic; usually a thin comfort layer rather than the whole insole | Moderate for its thickness | Solid elastomer, so breathability comes from holes or the cover above it | Low: it is elastic and springs back, but a thin layer has little depth on its own | Surface feel lasts; depth depends on the foam underneath |
| PORON® urethane | Cushioned, with a quick spring back after each step | Light, and effective in thin layers | Open microcellular structure lets air and moisture vapour move | Low: engineered to resist compression set | Keeps its thickness longer; replace when the heel stops springing back |
Compression set is the column that matters most for how long an insole stays comfortable. It is the share of thickness a material fails to recover after being squeezed for a long time, and the ASTM D395 test method for compression set describes it as a measure of a material’s ability to keep its elastic properties under prolonged compressive stress. A foam with poor compression set feels lovely on day one and thinner every week after that.
Softness is the column people notice first, but softness and comfort are not the same thing. If the “feel” column is what you are weighing up, our guide to what makes an insole feel cushioned looks at softness, rebound and bottoming out in more depth.
Gel insoles: firm, durable in shape, but heavy
Most gel insoles are a soft polymer gel sealed inside a thin plastic skin, often with a fabric top cover. A materials presentation by Rogers Corporation to the US footwear industry association, FDRA, on underfoot cushioning, describes gel as highly viscous, behaving much like a solid and keeping its shape even under compression. The same presentation notes its limited conformability, which gives a firm cushioning experience rather than a soft one.
That has clear upsides. Gel does not crush the way a cheap foam does, so a gel insole often looks much the same after months of use. It is also easy to wipe clean. The trade-offs are weight, because gel is dense, and heat, because a sealed gel layer does not let air or moisture through. Gel is common in heel pads and forefoot cushions as well as full-length insoles; if you are deciding between those formats, read our comparison of heel cups vs full-length insoles.
Gel also takes up space. A thick gel insole in a slim everyday shoe can lift the heel and crowd the toes, which is one reason people looking for insoles for trainers often end up with something thinner and lighter. For running shoes, see our guide to insoles for running.
Memory foam insoles: softest at first, quickest to flatten
Memory foam is a viscoelastic polyurethane: it gives slowly under pressure, softens as it warms up and recovers slowly when the load comes off. In an insole that produces the sinking, made-to-your-foot feeling that sells so many pairs.
The catch is durability. In an interview published by Rogers, which makes PORON®, a footwear materials distributor describes typical memory foams as attracting buyers with initial comfort but collapsing quickly because of their low resistance to compression set, permanently moulding to the shape of the foot after a short period of use. Rogers obviously has an interest in comparing other foams unfavourably, but the effect is easy to check at home: take out a well-used memory foam insole and look for a deep heel print that no longer recovers overnight.
Gel vs memory foam: which should you choose?
This is the comparison most people are actually making, and the honest answer depends on what you value.
- Feel: memory foam feels softer and more enveloping; gel feels firmer and springier.
- Durability of thickness: gel generally holds its shape for longer; memory foam tends to flatten.
- Weight: memory foam is lighter; gel adds noticeable weight to each shoe.
- Heat: both can feel warm in a closed shoe, gel because it does not breathe and memory foam because it holds warmth and moulds closely to the foot.
- Fit in the shoe: gel insoles are often thicker, so check there is room in the toe box and that your heel still sits in the heel cup.
If neither trade-off appeals, that is exactly why the third route, a layered foam insole, exists.
EVA, SEBS and PORON®: the foams inside most modern insoles
EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) is the light, springy closed-cell foam used in many shoe midsoles. It is cheap to mould, easy to shape and adds very little weight. The FDRA presentation notes that EVA permanently moulds and conforms to the foot after a period of wear, and that it takes on a firmer but less supportive feel after a short period of use. On its own it is a good base; as the only cushioning layer it can feel tired quite early.
SEBS (styrene-ethylene-butylene-styrene) is a thermoplastic elastomer: a soft, rubber-like material that stretches and springs back. In insoles, it usually appears as a thin comfort layer that gives a soft, slightly grippy feel. Because it is elastic it recovers well, but a thin layer has little depth on its own, so it works best on top of a resilient foam.
PORON® is a family of microcellular polyurethane foams from Rogers Corporation. On its PORON® Comfort page, Rogers describes a proprietary open-cell structure that averages about 100 microns per cell, engineered to keep its cushioning in dynamic conditions. The PORON® product range also includes PORON® ShockPad foam, which Rogers lists for impact protection, thin designs and excellent compression set resistance. In plain terms, it is a thin foam that is designed to keep its thickness. For the impact side of the story, see how shock-absorbing insoles work.
Why do the best insoles layer more than one material?
Look back at the table and a pattern stands out: every material is good at one or two things and weak at another. Gel holds its shape but is heavy and warm. Memory foam is soft but flattens. EVA is light but moulds. SEBS is soft but thin. PORON® keeps its thickness but is used in thin layers and needs a structure around it.
A layered insole puts each material where its strength counts and lets another layer cover its weakness. A light, flexible base keeps weight down and lets the insole bend with the shoe. A soft layer gives the first-step feel. A resilient foam sits under the heel and forefoot, where flattening shows first. A stiffer element under the midfoot stops the whole thing folding, and a breathable cover deals with warmth and sweat. That combination is harder to build than a single slab of gel or memory foam, which is why cheap insoles rarely do it.
A worked example: the BOLLSEN® Insoles layer stack
Our own insole is a layered EVA, SEBS and PORON® ShockPad insole, built along exactly those lines:
- EVA layer for flexibility, so the insole moves with the shoe.
- SEBS layer for softness underfoot.
- PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption, the layer chosen to resist flattening.
- Nylon Pebax shank for support, with a dynamic midfoot bridge that adapts to the foot.
- Breathable top layer with moisture management, plus ventilation holes that let air through the insole.
The insoles come in UK 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47). Buy your usual size, then trim the toe end to fine-tune the fit for each pair of shoes. They are removable, washable and can move between trainers, work boots and walking shoes. We rate them for 800 to 1,200 km, which is roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day, and every pair comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, so you can test them through real working weeks.
Cork, leather and carbon fibre in one line each
- Cork is a natural, fairly firm material that slowly moulds to the foot and is common in sandal footbeds.
- Leather is mostly used as a top cover: hard-wearing, pleasant against the skin and good at taking up moisture, but it adds little cushioning.
- Carbon fibre appears as thin, stiff plates that add rigidity rather than softness, mainly in specialist sports footwear.
How do you tell when any insole material is worn out?
Whatever the material, the same checks work. Press the heel area with your thumb: a good foam still springs back. Look for a deep heel print or a shiny, compressed patch under the ball of the foot. Check whether the top cover is peeling, bunching or worn through, and on gel insoles look for splits in the outer skin. If your feet feel at the end of the day the way they did before you started using the insoles, the cushioning has probably gone.
Heat and moisture shorten the life of most foams, so let insoles air-dry fully between long wears. If you are on your feet all shift, two pairs in rotation give each one time to recover, and our guide to the best insoles for standing all day covers the rest of the long-shift set-up. Work boots are a particularly warm, closed environment, so if that is where your insoles will live, our guide to insoles for work and safety boots is worth a look before you choose a material.
Pingback: Cushioned Insoles: What Really Makes Them Comfortable | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Best Insoles for Standing All Day: A Long-Shift Guide | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Shock Absorbing Insoles: How They Work | BOLLSEN
Pingback: Heel Cups vs Full-Length Insoles: Which Do You Need? | BOLLSEN