Insoles for Running: When a Comfort Insole Makes Sense (and When It Doesn’t)

⏱️ Estimated reading time: 13 min

Short answerA comfort insole suits easy runs, run-walk sessions and walking, while a slim running-specific insole suits racing in snug shoes. Swapping the insole can change fit, heel-to-toe drop and weight, so remove the original first, trim to fine-tune and test on short runs. Replace any insole once its heel stays dented or no longer springs back.
A runner on a park bench sliding a plain grey insole into a grey running shoe beside a tarmac path on an early autumn morning
On this page: Overview
    Summarize with AI

    Key Takeaways

    Not always. Many runners are happy with the insole their running shoes came with. A replacement makes sense when the original has flattened, when you want more cushioning on easy runs, or when the shoe feels slightly roomy. Running-specific insoles are worth a look if you race or run long distances in a snug, lightweight shoe.

    Yes, as long as there is room. Take the original insole out first so you are swapping one layer for another, then check that your heel stays put and your toes are not pressed against the top of the shoe. A full-length comfort insole suits easy runs, run-walk sessions and the walking you do in the same shoes.

    Go by wear rather than the calendar. Replace an insole once the heel area stays dented, no longer springs back when you press it or the top cover is wearing through. Our layered comfort insole is rated for 800 to 1,200 km, roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day.

    They can. A thicker insole lifts your foot inside the shoe, which takes up volume, can let the heel slip and can crowd the toes. An insole that is thicker at the heel than the original also adds a little to the shoe’s heel-to-toe drop. Compare the old and new insoles side by side before your first run.

    Yes, for a full-length replacement. Stacking two insoles almost always makes a running shoe too tight and lifts the heel out of the heel counter. Keep the original, though: it is the best template for trimming the new pair, and you can put it back if you change your mind.

    Running shoes come with an insole already, usually a thin foam sockliner that you barely notice. So the question is rarely whether you need an insole at all. It is whether the one in the box is the right one for the running you actually do, and if not, which kind of replacement makes more sense.

    There are two broad options. A general comfort insole is built for long hours on your feet and moves happily between trainers, work shoes and walking shoes. A running-specific insole is designed around the fit and weight of a running shoe. Both have a place, and the right choice depends on how far and how fast you run. If you want the bigger picture first, start with how to choose insoles. If your running shoes double as your everyday pair, our guide to insoles for everyday trainers covers that side.

    Comfort insole or running-specific insole?

    The two kinds overlap more than marketing suggests. Both sit under the whole foot, both add cushioning compared with a basic sockliner, and both can be taken out and washed. The differences are in the priorities. A comfort insole is designed to stay comfortable through a long day of standing and walking. A running-specific insole is usually designed to stay out of the way: slim, light and shaped to sit in a running shoe without changing how it fits.

    The table compares typical designs. Products vary within each group, so treat it as a guide to what to look for rather than a ranking.

    Full-length comfort insole vs running-specific insole: cushioning, weight, drop change and mileage
    What to compareFull-length comfort insoleRunning-specific insole
    CushioningGenerous and layered, tuned for comfort over long hours on your feet. Feels noticeably softer than a stock sockliner.Often firmer and thinner, so the shoe’s own midsole does most of the cushioning work.
    WeightUsually a little heavier than the thin sockliner it replaces, because of the extra layers and the shank.Usually kept light, since every gram is lifted with each stride.
    Drop changeDepends on its profile compared with the original insole. Check the heel and forefoot thickness side by side.Often designed to keep close to the shoe’s original fit and drop.
    MileageOur layered comfort insole is rated for 800 to 1,200 km, roughly 8 to 10 months at 100 kg and 8 hours a day.Varies widely by design. Check the maker’s guidance and look for the same wear signs.
    Best suited toEasy runs, run-walk sessions, walking and a shoe that also does everyday duty.Long runs, faster sessions and racing in a snug, lightweight shoe.

    The cushioning row is the one most people notice first. A soft layer feels good in the shop, but what matters on a run is whether the foam springs back step after step. Our guide to cushioned insoles explains why some soft insoles go flat, and the physics of impact is covered in how shock-absorbing insoles work.

    What changes when you swap the insole?

    A running shoe is designed as one system: upper, midsole, outsole and sockliner. Changing the sockliner changes three things you can feel straight away.

    Fit and volume. Running shoes tend to fit closely, especially lighter models. Every extra millimetre under the foot takes up space above it. If the new insole is thicker than the original, the foot sits higher in the shoe, the heel can lift out of the heel counter and the toes may brush the top of the toe box. Loosening the laces helps a little, but it also loosens the hold on your foot. The simple check is to stand in the shoes with the new insole in place: you should still have a thumb’s width in front of your longest toe, and your heel should not lift when you walk briskly up a step.

    Heel-to-toe drop. Drop is the difference between how high the heel sits and how high the forefoot sits in the shoe, and runners often pick shoes partly for it. An insole of even thickness that replaces a similar sockliner hardly changes the drop. An insole that is thicker under the heel than under the forefoot adds a little. Lay the old and new insoles side by side, then compare the heel and the forefoot edge. If you have chosen your shoes for a particular drop, this is worth thirty seconds of your time.

    Weight. A layered insole with a shank weighs more than a thin foam sockliner. On a steady 5 km or a run-walk session, most people never notice. On a fast session or a race, some runners do, and that is one reason racing shoes come with very light insoles. If you are not sure, run the same easy route with each set-up and see which one you reach for next time.

    Easy runs and walking vs racing

    Most running is easy running. Recovery jogs, weekend park runs, run-walk plans and the walking you do in the same pair make up the bulk of the miles for many people. The NHS Couch to 5K plan, for example, mixes running and walking, and its kit advice is simply running shoes that support your feet. For this kind of running, a full-length comfort insole is a sensible upgrade. The extra cushioning is welcome at an easy pace, the small weight difference does not matter, and the same pair can go back into your work shoes or walking shoes afterwards.

    Racing is different. Race shoes are usually snug and light, with thin insoles and little spare volume. That is where a running-specific insole, or simply the shoe’s own sockliner, tends to make more sense. Whatever you choose, test it on several training runs first. Race day is not the day to try a new insole.

    Many runners end up with both: a comfort set-up in an older pair of shoes for easy days and walking, and a slimmer set-up in the shoes they use for faster sessions.

    How long does a running insole last?

    Every foot strike squeezes the foam, and a run puts more load through each step than standing or walking. Some foams never fully recover their thickness. The loss is called compression set, and it is why a cheap soft insole can feel flat after a few weeks. Rogers Corporation, which makes PORON® urethane, notes in an article on footwear materials that typical memory foams collapse quickly because of their low resistance to compression set, while its PORON® materials are made for long-term performance in shoes. Rogers sells the material, so read that with its interest in mind, but it matches what most runners see with basic foam.

    Our layered insole is rated for 800 to 1,200 km, which works out at roughly 8 to 10 months for a 100 kg wearer on their feet 8 hours a day. Your own mileage depends on your weight, how often you run and how much of the week the insoles spend in other shoes. Rather than counting kilometres, watch for these signs:

    • A deep dent under the heel or the ball of the foot that does not recover overnight.
    • The heel area no longer springs back when you press it with your thumb.
    • The top cover is thinning, bunching or peeling.
    • Your usual route feels harder underfoot than it did when the insoles were new.

    Remember that the shoe wears too. In a running shoe the midsole does most of the cushioning work, and a fresh insole cannot bring a tired midsole back to life. If the midsole is visibly creased and compressed, new shoes are the answer, and a good insole can move across to the new pair. More detail on care and wear signs is in our guide on when to replace insoles.

    How to fit a new insole in running shoes

    1. Buy your usual size. Choose the size you wear in shoes, not a size up or down.
    2. Take the original insole out. Most running shoes have a removable sockliner. If yours is glued in, the shoe may not have room for a full-length replacement.
    3. Trim to fine-tune. Lay the original on top of the new insole, line up the heels and trim the toe end a little at a time. Shoes of the same size vary, so trim for each pair.
    4. Check the fit standing up. The insole should lie flat with no curl at the toe or the edges, and your heel should sit snugly in the heel counter.
    5. Start with a short, easy run. Then build up over a week before you use the new set-up for a long run.

    When an insole is not the answer

    A comfort insole makes running shoes more comfortable. It is not a treatment, and it is not a substitute for an insole prescribed by a podiatrist. Tired legs after a hard week are normal, but pain that keeps coming back, gets worse or does not settle with rest is a reason to get advice rather than change your kit. The NHS guidance on foot pain explains when to see a GP, and the Royal College of Podiatry can help you find a podiatrist near you. If you are weighing up a shop-bought insole against a prescribed one, see the difference between insoles and orthotics.

    Where a layered comfort insole fits in

    Our own insole is a general comfort insole, so it belongs in the left-hand column of the table above: easy runs, run-walk sessions, walking and shoes that do double duty. BOLLSEN® Insoles, rated for 800–1,200 km, are built in layers:

    • EVA for flexibility, so the insole bends with the shoe at toe-off.
    • SEBS for a soft feel underfoot.
    • PORON® ShockPad foam for shock absorption.
    • Nylon Pebax shank for support, with a dynamic midfoot bridge that adapts to the foot.
    • Breathable top layer that manages moisture, with ventilation holes.

    They come in UK sizes 4 to 12.5 (EU 36 to 47). Buy your size, then trim to fine-tune the fit in each pair of shoes. They are removable and washable, so after a wet run you can take them out, wash them and let them air-dry. For long days standing rather than running, see our pick of the best insoles for standing all day, and if you are comparing materials, gel vs foam insoles are covered separately.

    The honest test is your own shoes on your own routes. Every pair comes with a 40-day money-back guarantee, which gives you a few weeks of easy runs before you decide.

    One thought on “Insoles for Running: When a Comfort Insole Makes Sense (and When It Doesn’t)”

    1. Pingback: Gel vs Foam Insoles: Which Material Is Better? | BOLLSEN

    Comments are closed.